Car insurance is mandatory in Ontario, but that doesn’t mean you’re locked into one provider forever. With changing driving habits, inflation, and evolving personal circumstances, many Ontario drivers are reassessing their auto insurance needs. Whether you’re looking for cheaper premiums, better customer service, or more comprehensive coverage, switching insurers might be a smart move.
In this comprehensive guide, we’ll walk you through how to switch car insurance companies in Ontario, when it makes sense to do so, and tips to avoid costly mistakes.
Can You Switch Auto Insurance Providers in Ontario?
Yes, absolutely. Ontario’s car insurance market is privatized, which means you can switch insurance companies at any time. However, it’s regulated by the Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario (FSRA), so all insurers must meet minimum coverage requirements.
Minimum Car Insurance Requirements in Ontario:
- $200,000 in third-party liability coverage (most drivers opt for higher limits)
- Statutory accident benefits
- Direct compensation – property damage (DCPD)
- Uninsured automobile coverage
While these minimums are standard, prices, customer service quality, discounts, and additional perks can vary widely among insurers. Our isure brokers will compare several insurance quotes against your current insurance policy to understand the pros and cons of making a change, such as cancellation costs, policy prices, coverages, discounts and claims services. Your isure broker can help you compare quotes to ensure you have the right coverage!
Why Consider Switching Car Insurance Companies?
Switching insurance companies could lead to cost savings, improved coverage, or better service. Here are some common reasons Ontarians choose to change providers:
1. Lower Premiums
Your life circumstances change — and so should your premiums. You might find a more competitive rate with another insurer, especially if:
- You recently had a ticket or accident drop off your record
- You’ve moved to a new location
- You’re bundling policies for a multi-product discount
Read our tips on how to lower your auto insurance premiums without switching insurers.
2. Poor Claims Experience or Customer Service
If your insurer has been unresponsive or difficult to deal with during a claim, it might be time for a change.
3. Better Policy Perks
Some insurers offer valuable extras like:
- Free roadside assistance
- Waived deductible for not-at-fault claims
- New vehicle replacement
- Gap insurance for leased or financed cars
4. Major Life Events
Changes such as getting married, moving, adding a driver, or buying a new vehicle can all affect your insurance rates. These moments are ideal times to shop around.
When Is the Best Time to Switch Car Insurance?
Technically, you can switch any time — but there’s a better time to do it:
At Renewal
Switching at the end of your policy term is ideal. You’ll avoid cancellation fees, and it’s easy to coordinate the changeover.
After a Major Life Change
Bought a new car? Adding a teen driver? Moving to a different city? All these affect your premium, so it’s a good time to compare options.
When Your Rates Increase
If your current insurer raises your premiums at renewal, get competitive quotes to see if you can find better value elsewhere.
Be Mindful of Cancellation Fees
Cancelling mid-term can result in short-rate cancellation penalties, which might reduce your refund amount. Check your insurer’s cancellation policy or use our cancellation fee calculator to estimate costs.
How to Switch Insurance Companies in Ontario (Step-by-Step)
Switching your auto insurance is easier than you might think, especially with the help of a licensed broker. Here’s a step-by-step breakdown:
1. Shop Around for Quotes
Start by comparing quotes from multiple insurance providers. An insurance broker, like isure, can do this legwork for you and ensure you’re comparing similar policies with:
- Equal liability limits
- Matching deductibles
- Comparable coverages (collision, comprehensive, etc.)
- Available discounts
Tip: Don’t just look at the base price. Consider customer service reviews, claims satisfaction, and added perks.
2. Re-evaluate Your Coverage Needs
Are you still driving as much as before? Has the value of your car dropped enough to remove collision coverage? Will you benefit from usage-based (telematics) insurance?
Life changes = insurance changes. Evaluate:
- Do you need higher liability coverage?
- Will bundling home and auto save you money?
- Are you eligible for new discounts?
3. Ask Around & Research Reviews
Ask friends, family, or coworkers about their insurance providers. Check online reviews for customer service and claims handling. You want an insurer that’s reliable when you need them most.
4. Secure Your New Policy First
Never cancel your current insurance before the new one is active. To avoid a lapse in coverage (which can affect your premiums or driving record), ensure your new policy is active and in writing. Additionally, ensure you’ve signed and submitted all necessary documents, and that the start date overlaps slightly with your current policy.
5. Cancel Your Old Policy (With Caution)
After you’ve found the best price for insurance, give your current provider a call before you commit to switching to the new company. Check if your current company will match the quote you got from a competitor and ask, in detail, about the company’s cancellation process. If they won’t match it, request cancellation in writing, and ensure you receive confirmation and any applicable refund.
You may need to give your insurer advance notice to cancel your policy — sometimes, as much as 30 days is required — as well as pay a small fee to cancel your policy. However, as mentioned, you will receive a refund for the majority of your unused premium once you cancel.
Important: Make sure to avoid any gaps in insurance coverage!
You also want to make sure your policy dates line up and that you have no coverage gaps. If you start your new policy without cancelling your old one and it renews automatically, you may be subject to penalties. Driving without insurance can cause you to lose your license. Even if you aren’t caught, gaps in coverage can eventually lead to a premium hike. It’s much better to have a few days of overlapping coverage than to take the risk of being uninsured. Once you have proof of insurance from your new provider, contact your previous insurance company to cancel your policy.
6. Notify Your Lender
If your car is leased or financed, notify your leasing or finance company of the insurance change. They need to update their records and may require a copy of your new policy.
Can You Switch Car Insurance Before Renewal?
Yes — but there may be fees. Here’s what to expect:
Prorated Refund
You’re refunded for the unused portion of your policy without penalty.
Short-Rate Cancellation
Your insurer may deduct a penalty (often around one month’s premium) before refunding the remainder.
Pro Tip: If fees are too high, it might be better to wait until renewal to switch.
When Not to Switch Car Insurance
There are times when switching might not be in your best interest:
- You’ve had a recent at-fault accident or traffic violation
- You just started a policy and will incur large cancellation fees
- You’re in the middle of a claim
In these cases, it may be better to stick it out until renewal.
The Benefits of Using an Insurance Broker
Insurance brokers, like the team at isure, work for you — not the insurance companies. We can:
- Compare quotes from top-rated Ontario insurers
- Explain differences in coverage, limits, and exclusions
- Help you avoid coverage gaps and cancellation penalties
- Manage all paperwork, so switching is seamless
Bundle and Save: Consider Combining Home and Auto
If you’re switching car insurance, it might also be a good time to bundle your home or tenant insurance. Most insurers offer up to 15-25% discounts when you bundle.
Bonus Tip: Don’t forget to notify your mortgage lender if you’re changing home insurance providers.
Final Thoughts: Is Switching Right for You?
Switching insurance companies in Ontario can be a smart financial move — as long as you do it the right way. It’s not just about the lowest price, but the best overall value: reliable coverage, responsive service, and peace of mind when you need it most.
Let an experienced insurance broker like isure help you explore your options, guide you through the process, and ensure you’re protected every step of the way.
Discover effective strategies to lower your auto premium without changing Read more
When researching car insurance, finding the correct information can sometimes Read more
Thinking about changing insurance companies? We've got what you need Read more
