While the overall cost of living is on the rise, the one increase leaving many concerned is in rental prices, especially in the GTA. For those who rent their homes, rising inflation is likely to drive up rents in the months ahead. Tracking spending has never been more important! When considering your expenses, how important is renter’s insurance during a recession?

How inflation affects your Renter’s Insurance coverage

High inflation increases the costs of your insurance coverage. As goods such as furniture, electronics, and clothing become more expensive due to inflation, replacing them becomes more costly. As a renter, that means inflation essentially weakens your renters’ insurance during a recession. What seemed like adequate coverage five years ago may now leave some of your property unprotected. You should verify that you have sufficient coverage each year so you aren’t underinsured in a worst-case scenario.

Climbing rental prices

Canadians are now less likely to own a home than they were a decade ago. Rental households have grown at more than twice the pace of owner households in the past decade, particularly among millennials ages 25 to 40. Coupled with a rising trend of condominium construction, these all point to an increased demand for rental dwellings across Canada’s large cities. According to Rentals.ca, the average rent for all property types across Canada is $2,060 per month, down 2.4% annually in 2026.

Do you need rental/tenant insurance during a recession?

As you weigh your monthly costs, you may wonder whether renters’ insurance during a recession is a necessary expense to carry. Many insurance experts believe that insurers may see a decline in interest for tenant insurance. Tight budgets can lead you to prioritize specific bills over others. In Ontario, tenant insurance is not legally mandatory. This means you do not need to purchase a tenant insurance policy if you feel it is unnecessary or if you want to save more money. Renters may forego tenant insurance even more during a recession.

A monthly movie channel subscription, for example, can cost roughly the same as a tenant insurance policy. Being unable to afford going out has made subscriptions like these seem more necessary than insurance. However, it’s important to note that not carrying renters’ insurance during a recession exposes you to more risk. It’s also important to note that nothing prevents a landlord from requiring it in their lease agreement. Your landlord is allowed to make acquiring tenant insurance a part of the lease terms, and therefore, you may not be able to drop rental insurance coverage.

What does renter’s insurance cover?

As a tenant, you are responsible for insuring the home and for the necessary repairs involved in owning property. However, they are not responsible for what may happen to your personal property in the event of an unexpected accident.

There are three types of coverage in any renter’s insurance policy:

  1. Contents insurance, which protects your contents if they’re stolen or suffer damage and will cover the cost to repair or replace most household items.
  2. Liability insurance, which covers you if a guest injures themselves in your space and protects you if you’re responsible for damage to other people’s property.
  3. Additional living expenses cover the cost of living elsewhere if you can’t live in your rental space due to an insured peril. This includes hotel bills, restaurant meals and moving expenses.

To learn more about renters’ or tenants’ insurance, please click here.

Some tips to battle inflation during a recession

You have no control over the inflation rate, but you can control your policy and your choice of insurance provider. Here are five practical steps to ensure that your insurance protects your items for a fair amount:

1. Review your policy limits

How much coverage you need depends on the value of your possessions — and in the insurance world, there are two ways to determine the value. You may hear of Actual Cash Value (ACV) and Replacement Cost Value (RCV). ACV is the current cost of your personal property after depreciation, less the deductible. RCV pays you what it will cost to get a similar item brand new.

2. Reach out to your insurance provider at renewal

When your renter’s insurance policy renews, take the time to speak with your insurance provider or isure broker. I think it’s essential to have a professional review your policy to narrow down your needs and make adjustments as needed. Be sure to ask why your insurance policy is increasing in cost. That way, you’ll know if it’s simply due to insurance inflation, in relation to a claim or an increase in property coverage. This information will get you one step closer to reducing your premiums. Ask about available discounts. There may be several ways your isure broker can help you save money if they’re familiar with your particular situation.

To learn more about possible discounts to combat inflation, please click here.

3. Make sure everything’s covered

As things get more expensive to replace, you don’t want to have any blind spots in your coverage. Go through your policy’s terms and conditions to make sure it covers all your property (even the stuff in your shed or your special collectibles). Also, consider new items you’ve purchased and how much it will cost to replace your valuables. With this in mind, you may need to increase your coverage rather than reduce it to save in the event of a claim.

4. Mitigate your risks for a potential discount

Taking measures that protect your property is always a good idea to help you avoid insurance claims in the first place. You can qualify for special discounts on your personal property insurance policy by informing your insurer about steps you’ve taken. For instance, you can use a tracker on your e-bike to reduce the risk of theft or loss. Similarly, you can install a security system to protect against burglary and property damage.

5. Shop around for the best policy

You wouldn’t buy a new vehicle or an expensive electronic without comparison shopping – your insurance coverage should be no different. While getting quotes, don’t forget to consider the additional discounts each insurer offers. Those extra perks can add up and tip the scales!

Final thoughts on renters’ insurance during a recession

Although inflation is likely to rise in the short term, experts expect it to level off and begin to decline by the end of the year. However, a downward trend in inflation does not mean that your rent price will drop as well. Rent prices will most likely increase, but at a slower rate. Inflation can increase your insurance expenses as a result. That’s why it’s essential to review your policy and coverage limits yearly to make sure you have adequate coverage. To answer the question of how vital renters’ insurance is during a recession, the short answer is critical.

As inflation drives up prices, you want to make sure your purchases are protected. Similarly, should you need to file a claim for loss or damage to your property, it will cost much more to replace items you bought even three years ago. While rental insurance may be at par with a TV subscription, you’ll get much more value and peace of mind in the end while waiting out the recession.

Are You Renting? Keep Your Belongings (and Yourself) Safe.

Protect what matters most. Get your free tenant insurance quote today!

Tenant Insurance CTA Image
review image
Related Articles
recession and home insurance - Saving investment banking finance concept. Stack of coins with piggy bank on the table. Growth of loan and investment business idea. Asset Management, Funds, Liabilities, Deposits, Income, Successful.
Recessions and Home Insurance: What to Expect

Many homeowners fear for what the year ahead may mean Read more

ontario tenant insurance or 'renters insurance' paper documents on a desk with a pen
Ontario Tenant Insurance: Essential for Every Renter

Renters need insurance as much as homeowners do. Unfortunately, many Read more

A woman sits on the couch in her rental property on her laptop.
Tenant Insurance Myths That May Cost You

In a recent study of Canadian renters, nearly half of Read more